our guys are in every position EXCEPT leadership, but the establishment outer party would love nothing more than a chance to purge them.
I want MAGA, America First, The Right, or whatever you choose to call it to be the first in line to take power when the Mitch McConnels of the world finally loosen their grip (read: slump over the sides of their wheelchairs for the last time right there on the senate floor.)
I am not trusting the plan, but the sheer buildup of RW legal talent between 2020 & 24 and the largest hiring of immigration judges ever, (explicitly as deportation judges) is a hint that we can actually play the kind of procedural games that win championships. What that takes, is time.
What the dissident right movement proved is
1. a small group can move the needle ideologically
2. all the talk of decisive, yarvinesque, modern monarch action was counterproductive. We aren’t in the position to get a Bukele without living through a hell modern Americans can’t imagine, and 90% chance that if we do we still don’t get one.
As mentioned here, fishing in the rubicon is counterproductive, but so is getting mad that your representative isn’t crossing it. Yes they’d get couped so fast it would make our heads spin. Going back to Bukele, when he had supporters surround the parliament he also had >50% support within the walls. We don’t. What we can do is play moderate, act radical, and hire our guys as fast as we can at every turn.
I voted straight Red, but I did not FOR any Republican, every vote was a vote AGAINST the Left and AGAINST their proposed measures. But I am in Commiefornia so my voting is mostly a performative ritual of defiance. Just a reminder on paper to myself that I say NO.
I will not be voting for GOP candidates simply because they no longer deserve my vote, period. I do not have, and I do not need, any complicated emotional justification about "punishing" anyone. I'm simply not going to support candidates who have no use for me anymore.
Also, I want to weigh in on this whole idea of "building local communities." Specifically, I want to say that it is totally asinine. I have been hearing this from alternative political voices for more than 25 years; if it were possible to build meaningful and resilient local communities, we would have them by now. The scaling laws make it impossible to do so. Local communities simply are not as efficient as the national and global institutions they would need to subvert. Furthermore, there is nothing sacrosanct about a local community. Local communities can be just as dysfunctional and sinful as the cosmopolitan mass, and they have much less power to enforce their will. I am now at the point when I no longer take seriously anybody who talks about building local communities. This is not a serious strategy.
The only strategy that has a chance of disrupting the global power structure, and that ordinary people can effectuate without breaking the law, is some kind of economic boycott, specifically debt disruption. Stop consuming, pay off all old debts, and refuse to borrow any more money even if it means personal sacrifice. Done on a large scale, the resulting deflation would bring about the end of the financialized era, and financialization is the principal source and power of the evils in the world today.
Dude, it’s like these idiots didn’t even read your article. These sorts of retards piss me off more than democrats do and when we take power [the rest of this comment has been redacted for it was written in a fit of emotion]
You will never take power again given the USA's demographics and your emotional and mental enslavement to the USA. Trump's presidency is your peak. It's all downhill from here for you.
Wait, so we, "ordinary people" are going to defeat the global hegemonic liberal power structure by "some kind of economic boycott," where we consume less and pay off our debt?
Brother, please. Hoping you're a holy celibate monk or a happily married man who just stopped by, because if you're an incel this level of being wrong is simply inexcusable.
The best counter to the NJF argument. Use your judgment and prudence everyone. We all know who the enemy is, and whatever happens or whatever your particular take, we're all in this together.
The republicans are always going to be marginally better than the democrats, and marginally better won’t matter if every incremental gain will be swept away the second you lose a single election — like sandcastles with the tide.
What I heard is “the Trump admin has been disappointing, but suck it up and vote Republican anyways because it’s better than the alternative”. My understanding is that he doesn’t see any salvation in traditional politics, so the best you can hope for is to buy time to build parallel institutions.
I didn’t vote for either of them, but the argument for Kamala was that Trump was going to be SUCH a disaster that it would kill any chance for a Republican to be elected for a generation. Which… we seem to be on track for. Gen Z enthusiastically supported him in 2024 and he’s shat on them at every opportunity since. In addition, he’s led the movement so very astray, to the point where his supporters are assaulting people wearing “release the Epstein files” shirts. He also appointed such awful people that it’s clear that the Republicans are not only controlled opposition, but they are psychopaths incapable of basic governance.
I voted Democrat. I don’t have much more faith in them than I do in the Republicans, but the Democrats at least give us a 1% chance of disentangling from Israel. The Republicans give us a 0% chance.
I'll add that the AI-driven surveillance panopticon that BP is so concerned about was actively accelerated by Trump & Elon (Project Stargate etc.), on top of the economic effects of inflating ANOTHER insane debt-driven speculation bubble. (I'm not convinced that fears about mass unemployment or Skynet scenarios are totally unfounded either.)
The decision to escalate the war in Iran was AFAICT also an unforced error brought about by overconfidence after the coup in Venezuela and the sheer stupidity of believing Bibi's advice. Or... I dunno, if you believe in the Epstein/Mossad blackmail explanation, that's not exactly a point in Trump's favour.
Does all of this outweigh the benefits of better border control and less persecution from the state? Maybe, maybe not, but it doesn't seem inevitable to me that Kamala et al would have done exactly the same.
The best thing I can say for Trump's decisions here is that he might have (unintentionally) accelerated the planet's economic collapse to the point where China will be knocked out of play, thus ending the AI arms race, and maaaybe the US + Europe enter civil war during his current term. YMMV, of course.
I am done as well. Voting for libertarians where I can and not voting for any GOP at all, they are traitors. Our founding fathers would place their loyalty in principles, not a cuckolded political party. They would have rebelled a long time ago. Thirty years of trying to change this rigged system. It's time to call out its b.s. They even rig the system locally at the county level, ramming through data centers against the will of the people. Private Equity is buying up everything, including elections. We have them as our candidates. It is not emotional to make an informed decision, it is reality! If people cannot man-up and face reality now, they never will. Collapse is ugly and deadly. We will face it and instead of worrying about these political people who destroyed our country....I implore you all to prepare for what is coming and take care of your family.
"when we take power", you wrote, without explaining how that dream could be realistic given (1) the deteriorating demographic situation and (2) your acceptance of the enemy's morality. When challenged, you changed the topic.
Ok, so how does the USA's supposed IQ advantage wrt the rest of the world have any bearing on who in the USA rules the USA? Isn't this differential relevant instead to the pecking order among the world's various states?
You make good points, and I am not saying you did specifically, but I feel where the movement went wrong was in building Trump up too high.
He was always unfit for the office, but everyone on the right praised him to the moon, so the leaders in this space should hardly be shocked at the resistance of trying to keep people on board.
I get it, it’s elections, you have to match the intensity of the other side to an extent, but I feel this could have been avoided if more realistic expectations were set.
In 2028, we need to field serious candidates in every possible Republican primary...
This is the mission of Constitutional Action"
That's like a mission for basketball fans who are angry that the Washington Generals almost always lose to the Harlem Globetrotters. These fans not going to take it any more, so they conspire to insert a few "serious" players onto the Generals' roster.
Eventually the "serious" players are worn down by the experience and leave the team. The relationship between Generals and Globetrottere returns to the state entailed by evil founding principles and corporate charters.
And the reason this is doomed to fail is that the Trump cultists will shoot down every primary challenger because they have “insufficient loyalty to Trump.” I was disgusted when it happened to DeSantis, but I was willing to accept that the movement had made a mistake but was on the right trajectory long-term after Trump. But when the movement kicked out MTG and Massie, I was done. Republicans are going to have to claw back power after so thoroughly squandering it, and I have no interest in being part of that clawing back when it’s clear they’ll just squander it again. The establishment is fully in control of the GOP and there are millions of useful idiots doing their bidding (n.b. — I’m certainly not calling Bennett one of these useful idiots, even though he’s reached a different conclusion than I have.)
It’s funny, because in the Ryan/Cantor era of the Republican Party, Republican voters hated their elected officials and rebelled against them constantly, while Democrat voters dutifully followed Pelosi over the cliff over and over again. That dynamic has flipped. Trump has turned Republicans into dutiful followers, whereas Democrat voters hate people like Jeffries/Schumer and will give them big problems post-election.
It was unforeseeable 10 years ago, but if you dislike the establishment, the path for upsetting the establishment now clearly runs through the Democratic Party, not the Republicans.
I think it would have been strictly temporary, and once the election was over the Dems would have gone right back to the same strategy. Maaaaybe they would have slowed the pace a little relative to the Biden era, but that's just a part of 'boiling the frog' strategy.
our guys are in every position EXCEPT leadership, but the establishment outer party would love nothing more than a chance to purge them.
I want MAGA, America First, The Right, or whatever you choose to call it to be the first in line to take power when the Mitch McConnels of the world finally loosen their grip (read: slump over the sides of their wheelchairs for the last time right there on the senate floor.)
I am not trusting the plan, but the sheer buildup of RW legal talent between 2020 & 24 and the largest hiring of immigration judges ever, (explicitly as deportation judges) is a hint that we can actually play the kind of procedural games that win championships. What that takes, is time.
What the dissident right movement proved is
1. a small group can move the needle ideologically
2. all the talk of decisive, yarvinesque, modern monarch action was counterproductive. We aren’t in the position to get a Bukele without living through a hell modern Americans can’t imagine, and 90% chance that if we do we still don’t get one.
As mentioned here, fishing in the rubicon is counterproductive, but so is getting mad that your representative isn’t crossing it. Yes they’d get couped so fast it would make our heads spin. Going back to Bukele, when he had supporters surround the parliament he also had >50% support within the walls. We don’t. What we can do is play moderate, act radical, and hire our guys as fast as we can at every turn.
I voted straight Red, but I did not FOR any Republican, every vote was a vote AGAINST the Left and AGAINST their proposed measures. But I am in Commiefornia so my voting is mostly a performative ritual of defiance. Just a reminder on paper to myself that I say NO.
I will not be voting for GOP candidates simply because they no longer deserve my vote, period. I do not have, and I do not need, any complicated emotional justification about "punishing" anyone. I'm simply not going to support candidates who have no use for me anymore.
Also, I want to weigh in on this whole idea of "building local communities." Specifically, I want to say that it is totally asinine. I have been hearing this from alternative political voices for more than 25 years; if it were possible to build meaningful and resilient local communities, we would have them by now. The scaling laws make it impossible to do so. Local communities simply are not as efficient as the national and global institutions they would need to subvert. Furthermore, there is nothing sacrosanct about a local community. Local communities can be just as dysfunctional and sinful as the cosmopolitan mass, and they have much less power to enforce their will. I am now at the point when I no longer take seriously anybody who talks about building local communities. This is not a serious strategy.
The only strategy that has a chance of disrupting the global power structure, and that ordinary people can effectuate without breaking the law, is some kind of economic boycott, specifically debt disruption. Stop consuming, pay off all old debts, and refuse to borrow any more money even if it means personal sacrifice. Done on a large scale, the resulting deflation would bring about the end of the financialized era, and financialization is the principal source and power of the evils in the world today.
Good luck
Dude, it’s like these idiots didn’t even read your article. These sorts of retards piss me off more than democrats do and when we take power [the rest of this comment has been redacted for it was written in a fit of emotion]
You will never take power again given the USA's demographics and your emotional and mental enslavement to the USA. Trump's presidency is your peak. It's all downhill from here for you.
It’s all downhill for everyone if it’s all downhill for us. Like it or not the best and smartest are in the US. This is just pointless blackpilling.
Wait, so we, "ordinary people" are going to defeat the global hegemonic liberal power structure by "some kind of economic boycott," where we consume less and pay off our debt?
Brother, please. Hoping you're a holy celibate monk or a happily married man who just stopped by, because if you're an incel this level of being wrong is simply inexcusable.
Amen
The best counter to the NJF argument. Use your judgment and prudence everyone. We all know who the enemy is, and whatever happens or whatever your particular take, we're all in this together.
Vote harder that’ll fix it.
The republicans are always going to be marginally better than the democrats, and marginally better won’t matter if every incremental gain will be swept away the second you lose a single election — like sandcastles with the tide.
I don't think you understood the article, since your comment does not address its points.
What I heard is “the Trump admin has been disappointing, but suck it up and vote Republican anyways because it’s better than the alternative”. My understanding is that he doesn’t see any salvation in traditional politics, so the best you can hope for is to buy time to build parallel institutions.
What am I missing?
Marginally better does matter if you buy time to build parallel institutions.
I didn’t vote for either of them, but the argument for Kamala was that Trump was going to be SUCH a disaster that it would kill any chance for a Republican to be elected for a generation. Which… we seem to be on track for. Gen Z enthusiastically supported him in 2024 and he’s shat on them at every opportunity since. In addition, he’s led the movement so very astray, to the point where his supporters are assaulting people wearing “release the Epstein files” shirts. He also appointed such awful people that it’s clear that the Republicans are not only controlled opposition, but they are psychopaths incapable of basic governance.
I voted Democrat. I don’t have much more faith in them than I do in the Republicans, but the Democrats at least give us a 1% chance of disentangling from Israel. The Republicans give us a 0% chance.
I'll add that the AI-driven surveillance panopticon that BP is so concerned about was actively accelerated by Trump & Elon (Project Stargate etc.), on top of the economic effects of inflating ANOTHER insane debt-driven speculation bubble. (I'm not convinced that fears about mass unemployment or Skynet scenarios are totally unfounded either.)
The decision to escalate the war in Iran was AFAICT also an unforced error brought about by overconfidence after the coup in Venezuela and the sheer stupidity of believing Bibi's advice. Or... I dunno, if you believe in the Epstein/Mossad blackmail explanation, that's not exactly a point in Trump's favour.
Does all of this outweigh the benefits of better border control and less persecution from the state? Maybe, maybe not, but it doesn't seem inevitable to me that Kamala et al would have done exactly the same.
The best thing I can say for Trump's decisions here is that he might have (unintentionally) accelerated the planet's economic collapse to the point where China will be knocked out of play, thus ending the AI arms race, and maaaybe the US + Europe enter civil war during his current term. YMMV, of course.
I am done as well. Voting for libertarians where I can and not voting for any GOP at all, they are traitors. Our founding fathers would place their loyalty in principles, not a cuckolded political party. They would have rebelled a long time ago. Thirty years of trying to change this rigged system. It's time to call out its b.s. They even rig the system locally at the county level, ramming through data centers against the will of the people. Private Equity is buying up everything, including elections. We have them as our candidates. It is not emotional to make an informed decision, it is reality! If people cannot man-up and face reality now, they never will. Collapse is ugly and deadly. We will face it and instead of worrying about these political people who destroyed our country....I implore you all to prepare for what is coming and take care of your family.
"when we take power", you wrote, without explaining how that dream could be realistic given (1) the deteriorating demographic situation and (2) your acceptance of the enemy's morality. When challenged, you changed the topic.
Ok, so how does the USA's supposed IQ advantage wrt the rest of the world have any bearing on who in the USA rules the USA? Isn't this differential relevant instead to the pecking order among the world's various states?
You make good points, and I am not saying you did specifically, but I feel where the movement went wrong was in building Trump up too high.
He was always unfit for the office, but everyone on the right praised him to the moon, so the leaders in this space should hardly be shocked at the resistance of trying to keep people on board.
I get it, it’s elections, you have to match the intensity of the other side to an extent, but I feel this could have been avoided if more realistic expectations were set.
In 2028, we need to field serious candidates in every possible Republican primary...
This is the mission of Constitutional Action"
That's like a mission for basketball fans who are angry that the Washington Generals almost always lose to the Harlem Globetrotters. These fans not going to take it any more, so they conspire to insert a few "serious" players onto the Generals' roster.
Eventually the "serious" players are worn down by the experience and leave the team. The relationship between Generals and Globetrottere returns to the state entailed by evil founding principles and corporate charters.
And the reason this is doomed to fail is that the Trump cultists will shoot down every primary challenger because they have “insufficient loyalty to Trump.” I was disgusted when it happened to DeSantis, but I was willing to accept that the movement had made a mistake but was on the right trajectory long-term after Trump. But when the movement kicked out MTG and Massie, I was done. Republicans are going to have to claw back power after so thoroughly squandering it, and I have no interest in being part of that clawing back when it’s clear they’ll just squander it again. The establishment is fully in control of the GOP and there are millions of useful idiots doing their bidding (n.b. — I’m certainly not calling Bennett one of these useful idiots, even though he’s reached a different conclusion than I have.)
It’s funny, because in the Ryan/Cantor era of the Republican Party, Republican voters hated their elected officials and rebelled against them constantly, while Democrat voters dutifully followed Pelosi over the cliff over and over again. That dynamic has flipped. Trump has turned Republicans into dutiful followers, whereas Democrat voters hate people like Jeffries/Schumer and will give them big problems post-election.
It was unforeseeable 10 years ago, but if you dislike the establishment, the path for upsetting the establishment now clearly runs through the Democratic Party, not the Republicans.
Why was it a mistake
Are you under the impression that the Biden administration regretted opening the border because they thought it was bad for the country
You're not naive enough to think this was anything but a tactical maneuver before the election, right?
I think it would have been strictly temporary, and once the election was over the Dems would have gone right back to the same strategy. Maaaaybe they would have slowed the pace a little relative to the Biden era, but that's just a part of 'boiling the frog' strategy.
Yep. That's just what they said at Valley Forge.
Bro, its been 250 years, get a new historical reference. AA was right, our sphere really has no new ideas since 2018
No one knows what the future holds. Emotional response. Womanly.
To be fair, Trump may have moved the system collapse forward by a couple of years, at the cost of destroying most of his popular support.